What makes a horror movie truly unforgettable? According to the highest-voted opinions on our subreddit Creepybonfire, it’s those gut-wrenching, heartbreaking horror movie endings that linger long after the credits roll.
That’s why we’ve gathered twelve of the most impactful ones, based on user votes, to take you on a chilling journey through the best of terrifying finales. Get ready to scream, cry, and maybe even laugh at how cruel these twists can be. Buckle up, horror fans; this list is not for the faint-hearted!
Needless to say the article contains spoilers.
The Mist (2007)
What makes a film stick with you? According to Reddit user Upset-Inside8719, it’s the gut-wrenching endings, and The Mist delivers just that. Directed by Frank Darabont and based on Stephen King’s novella, the movie plunges a small town into a mist filled with terrifying creatures. The real horror lies within a supermarket, where fear and desperation reign. In the end, protagonist David Drayton, out of options and hope, mercy-kills his companions, including his son, only to be rescued by the military moments later. This devastating twist leaves viewers reeling, showcasing how fragile hope can be. Ready to scream at the screen? Grab some tissues and dive into The Mist.
The Skeleton Key (2005)
Reddit user FairyLiveShow points to The Skeleton Key as a masterclass in heartbreaking horror movie endings. This 2005 film, starring Kate Hudson, takes us to the dark bayous of Louisiana. Caroline, a hospice nurse, takes a job in an old mansion, only to uncover a web of dark secrets and hoodoo magic. The twist? Caroline tries to save an elderly man from a sinister plot, only to find herself trapped in his body through a hoodoo spell. Her spirit is condemned to wither away in the paralyzed man’s body, while the villains enjoy her youth. This shocking conclusion flips the script on heroism, leaving viewers haunted by its cruel irony. If you love a twist that lingers, The Skeleton Key is your ticket.
Hereditary (2018)
Another one highlights Hereditary as a standout for its haunting and heart-wrenching finale. Directed by Ari Aster, this 2018 film takes family drama to terrifying new heights. The story follows the Graham family as they unravel dark secrets after the death of their secretive grandmother. The climax? It’s a gut punch. Peter, the teenage son, becomes the vessel for a demon named Paimon, orchestrated by his own grandmother’s cult. As his mother Annie desperately tries to save him, she meets a gruesome end, and Peter’s identity is erased. The film closes with a chilling scene of the cult welcoming their new leader in his body, leaving the audience reeling from the sheer horror and tragedy of it all. Hereditary doesn’t just scare; it devastates, making it a must-watch for those who appreciate a powerful, emotionally charged twist.
The Strangers (2008)
Reddit user Justhuman963 singles out The Strangers for its deeply unsettling conclusion. Released in 2008 and directed by Bryan Bertino, this home invasion thriller stars Liv Tyler and Scott Speedman as a couple staying in a secluded vacation home. Masked intruders terrorize them throughout the night. After a relentless night of fear and violence, the killers brutally murder the couple just as dawn breaks. They unmask and leave, telling a pair of young Mormon boys, “It’ll be easier next time.” This chilling end leaves viewers with a sense of hopelessness and dread, making The Strangers a haunting reminder of random, senseless violence.
Drag Me To Hell (2009)
LostCanoe points to Drag Me to Hell as a prime example of a heartbreaking horror movie ending. Directed by Sam Raimi, this 2009 film follows Christine Brown, a loan officer who denies an old woman an extension on her mortgage. This decision earns her a curse that promises to drag her to hell in three days. Christine fights desperately to lift the curse, believing she’s succeeded after a series of harrowing encounters. Just as she’s about to embark on a happy future, she realizes she’s been holding the wrong item to break the curse. In a gut-wrenching finale, she is literally dragged to hell in front of her horrified boyfriend.Â
Explore the best Spanish horror movies
Funny Games (1997)
Conscious_Living3532 shouts-out Funny Games for its gut-wrenching and unsettling conclusion. Directed by Michael Haneke, this 1997 psychological horror film (which he remade in 2007) follows a family whose vacation turns into a nightmare when two young men take them hostage. The captors’ sadistic games lead to psychological torture and brutal violence. Despite the family’s desperate attempts to escape, the intruders methodically kill them one by one. The film ends with the killers moving on to their next target, leaving the audience in shock and despair. Funny Games delivers a harrowing commentary on violence and viewer complicity, making it a must-watch for those who appreciate a horror film that challenges and disturbs to the core.
Would You Rather (2012)
Would You Rather also is a prime example of heartbreaking horror movie endings. Directed by David Guy Levy, this 2012 film centers on Iris, a young woman desperate to save her sick brother. She joins a deadly game hosted by a sadistic aristocrat, where contestants must inflict pain on themselves or others to survive. Each round becomes increasingly brutal and twisted. After enduring unspeakable torment and emerging as the last survivor, Iris returns home to find her brother has committed suicide, believing she will never return.Â
The Descent (UK Ending) (2005)
Tkyang99 brings out The Descent as a top contender for heartbreaking horror movie endings. Directed by Neil Marshall, this 2005 film follows a group of friends on a spelunking adventure that goes horribly wrong. Trapped deep underground, they encounter a horde of terrifying, flesh-eating creatures. The horror intensifies as the group is picked off one by one. In the original ending, Sarah, the last survivor, escapes the cave only to realize it was all an illusion. She’s still trapped, facing certain death as the creatures close in. This crushing realization leaves viewers with a profound sense of despair. The Descent masterfully combines claustrophobic terror with emotional depth, making it a must-watch for fans of horror that lingers long after the credits roll.
Night of the Living Dead (1968)
Reddit user BoxTalk17 points to Night of the Living Dead as a classic with a truly devastating ending. Directed by George A. Romero and released in 1968, this iconic film follows a group of strangers trapped in a farmhouse, trying to survive a zombie apocalypse. As the undead close in, internal conflicts tear the group apart. After a harrowing night, the sole survivor, Ben, emerges from the house only to be mistaken for a zombie by a rescue posse and shot dead. This tragic, ironic ending leaves viewers stunned, highlighting the senselessness of violence and the thin line between survival and death.
The Dark and the Wicked (2020)
Reddit user Ok_Produce_9308 spotlights The Dark and the Wicked for its devastating and haunting conclusion. Directed by Bryan Bertino, this 2020 film tells the story of siblings who return to their family farm to care for their dying father, only to encounter a malevolent force. As the siblings struggle to survive, they each fall victim to the entity’s relentless torment, succumbing to horrific fates. The film ends with a sense of utter hopelessness as the evil prevails, leaving no one unscathed.
Speak No Evil (2022)
Reddit user alison_bee high spots Speak No Evil for its gut-wrenching ending. Directed by Christian Tafdrup, this 2022 Danish film follows a Danish family visiting a Dutch family they met on vacation. What starts as a pleasant trip turns sinister as the hosts’ behavior becomes menacing. The horror intensifies when the Danish couple’s attempts to leave are thwarted. The parents are forced to watch helplessly as their child is taken away before they are killed.
Martyrs (2008)
LearningArcadeApp points to Martyrs for its profoundly disturbing and heartbreaking ending. Directed by Pascal Laugier, this 2008 French horror film follows Lucie and Anna, two women seeking revenge against those who tortured Lucie as a child. Their journey leads them to a secret society that inflicts extreme pain to reach enlightenment. Anna becomes their latest victim, enduring unimaginable suffering. In the end, she reaches a state of transcendence but whispers a message to the leader before taking her own life. The leader, shaken by Anna’s revelation, commits suicide, leaving the audience in shock and despair.
Join the Creepybonfire subreddit and become a member where you can share your opinions, thoughts, and everything related to the horror genre.
