Which horror films have earned the highest scores on Rotten Tomatoes? This list captures the scariest, smartest, and most unforgettable films that critics and audiences agree stand out. Expect a few surprises: some unexpected contenders claimed sky-high ratings, and a few familiar faces may be mysteriously absent. Rotten Tomatoes scores tell the story here—bringing both the classics and hidden gems to the spotlight. But hey, the following films didn’t not only hit a highscore on the Tomatometer, but in the audience-driven Popcornmeter. Ready to find out which horror movies hold the crown?
1. One Cut of the Dead (2017) – 100%
A low-budget zombie flick that became an instant classic. One Cut of the Dead is no ordinary horror movie. It plays with the genre by blending a zombie outbreak with a meta, behind-the-scenes twist that keeps the audience hooked. Its humor and originality made it an undeniable favorite, landing it a perfect score on Rotten Tomatoes.
2. The Wailing (2016) – 99%
South Korean horror at its best. The Wailing merges folklore with mystery, casting a sinister spell over a rural village where supernatural elements collide with a dark murder investigation. Na Hong-jin’s direction creates a disturbing tension that builds to an intense climax, earning it one of the highest Rotten Tomatoes scores for its depth and complex horror.
Don’t miss The Best Horror Movie Conspiracy Theories according to Reddit
3. Let the Right One In (2008) – 98%
This Swedish masterpiece reimagines vampire horror with a quiet but powerful tale of friendship and bloodlust. The story of Oskar and Eli is hauntingly beautiful and unsettling, striking a delicate balance between innocence and horror. Critics loved its originality and depth, awarding it one of the highest ratings for its impact on the genre.
4. Get Out (2017) – 98%
A game-changer in modern horror, Get Out combines social commentary with psychological terror. Jordan Peele’s thriller keeps viewers on edge, with each scene blending discomfort, humor, and fear. The film’s pointed take on race and identity makes it more than a horror flick—it’s a cultural landmark that earned a near-perfect Rotten Tomatoes score.
5. Bride of Frankenstein (1935) – 98%
James Whale’s sequel to Frankenstein elevated monster horror by bringing humanity to the grotesque. Bride of Frankenstein mixed terror with a tragic love story, creating a film that’s visually stunning and emotionally impactful. Whale’s technical brilliance and Elsa Lanchester’s unforgettable performance as the Bride gave it timeless appeal and a top spot in horror.
6. Jaws (1975) – 97%
Few movies have impacted beach culture like Jaws. Spielberg’s approach of showing the shark sparingly heightened the tension, making each appearance more terrifying. The simplicity of the plot—man vs. beast—gave audiences a primal fear of open water. Its masterful storytelling and groundbreaking approach to suspense keep it highly rated on Rotten Tomatoes.
7. King Kong (1933) – 97%
With groundbreaking special effects and a tragic narrative, King Kong went beyond expectations for a monster movie. This early Hollywood classic tells the story of a creature misunderstood, while thrilling audiences with visuals that were decades ahead of their time. Its high score celebrates its innovation and lasting influence in cinema.
8. Nosferatu (1922) – 97%
This silent film turned vampirism into an art form. Nosferatu introduced Count Orlok, a terrifying figure who cast a shadow over all vampire films to come. Max Schreck’s haunting performance and the film’s gothic visuals created an atmosphere that still holds up. Critics rank it among the best for its lasting impact and style.
9. Psycho (1960) – 97%
Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho shocked audiences with its brutal twists and innovative storytelling. Norman Bates’ psychological complexity gave the horror genre a new dimension, creating a character-driven dread that lingers. From the iconic shower scene to its climactic revelations, Psycho earned its high score for redefining the rules of horror.
10. Rosemary’s Baby (1968) – 97%
A disturbing look at motherhood, paranoia, and horror, Rosemary’s Baby keeps viewers in a constant state of unease. Mia Farrow’s fragile performance and Roman Polanski’s direction pull the audience into Rosemary’s increasing terror. The psychological horror unfolds with relentless tension, leaving audiences unnerved, which is why critics rank it among the best.
11. Eyes Without a Face (1960) – 97%
A poetic yet disturbing film, Eyes Without a Face combines elegance with horror as a guilt-ridden doctor conducts gruesome experiments on his disfigured daughter. Its haunting visuals and powerful story give it a unique place in horror cinema. This French film captivates critics and audiences alike with its eerie blend of beauty and horror.
12. Halloween (1978) – 96%
The birth of the slasher genre. Michael Myers and his unrelenting pursuit created a template for countless horror movies. John Carpenter’s Halloween uses simplicity and silence to terrify, with the relentless shape of Michael Myers haunting audiences. This film’s influence on horror and suspense explains its high Rotten Tomatoes score.
13. What We Do in the Shadows (2014) – 96%
Vampires meet flatmates in this dark comedy. What We Do in the Shadows combines horror and satire, following undead roommates struggling with the mundane aspects of modern life. This clever mockumentary format provides sharp wit and surprising charm, making it a critical favorite and earning it a top spot among horror comedies.
14. A Quiet Place (2018) – 96%
Silence has never been so terrifying. A Quiet Place draws its horror from the need to stay silent, where even a whisper can mean death. John Krasinski’s film delivers a fresh and innovative concept in horror, using silence to amplify tension. The Rotten Tomatoes score reflects its originality and nerve-wracking suspense.
15. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1919) – 96%
Considered the first true horror film, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari uses surreal sets and twisted visuals to tell a story of madness and manipulation. Its influence spans decades, as the expressionist style and unnerving storyline set the standard for psychological horror. Critics applaud its visionary direction, keeping it highly rated even a century later.
16. The Silence of the Lambs (1991) – 95%
Anthony Hopkins’ Hannibal Lecter is an unforgettable character, balancing menace with charm. The Silence of the Lambs dives into the psychological tension between Lecter and FBI trainee Clarice Starling, delivering horror without relying on the supernatural. This thriller keeps viewers on the edge, and its smart script and performances give it critical acclaim.
17. Aliens (1986) – 94%
Where Alien terrified, Aliens attacked. James Cameron’s action-packed sequel puts Ripley back in the line of fire, this time with an army of xenomorphs. Sigourney Weaver’s fierce portrayal and the relentless pacing earned this sequel a place in both horror and sci-fi history. Rotten Tomatoes reflects its success in blending action and fear.
18. Diabolique (1955) – 95%
A French suspense thriller with a twist that would make Hitchcock proud. Diabolique weaves a dark tale of betrayal and fear, creating a tension that builds to an unforgettable ending. Audiences and critics alike have praised its intricate plot and chilling atmosphere, giving it a solid place among classic horror films.
19. Shaun of the Dead (2004) – 92%
Horror-comedy at its finest, Shaun of the Dead manages to balance humor with scares. Simon Pegg and Nick Frost navigate a zombie apocalypse with wit and British charm, turning horror clichés into something fresh. The film’s clever writing and self-aware style earned it a high Rotten Tomatoes score and a loyal fanbase.
20. Alien (1979) – 93%
Claustrophobic, dark, and terrifying. Alien introduced the xenomorph as one of horror’s most memorable creatures, stalking the crew of the Nostromo with relentless menace. Ridley Scott’s direction brought horror to space, with slow-building tension and unforgettable scenes. Its influence on sci-fi horror keeps it among the top-rated films of all time.
Do you agree with those ratings? Share your favorite horror movie list with us on our Reddit Community.
Next up, don’t miss the Best Japanese Horror Movies You Need to Watch.