So, you’re itching to indulge in tales of humanity’s finest moments, wrapped up in the cozy format of a podcast? Well, grab your detective hat and a sense of morbid curiosity, because we’ve curated a list of true crime podcasts that will have you questioning your neighbor’s recycling habits. From Casefile to Freeway Phantom, these 19 true crime podcasts are ready to rattle your nerves and mess with your trust issues.
1. Casefile True Crime
Ever wondered what it’s like to have an anonymous Australian narrate gruesome tales into your ear? Look no further than Casefile True Crime. This podcast serves up meticulously researched cases with a side of “crikey.” The host’s soothing monotone will guide you through stories ranging from obscure Australian crimes to international mysteries, all while you ponder why anyone would ever leave their house.
Listen here: Casefile True Crime
These disturbing cursed objects that found their way into human hands and we explored the real stories behind them.
2. Invisible Choir
If you’re into haunting narratives that make you reconsider your life choices, Invisible Choir is your go-to. This podcast moves into the darkest corners of human nature, examining heinous acts through investigative storytelling and victim testimonials. It’s like a horror movie for your ears, minus the predictable jump scares.
Tune in at: Invisible Choir
3. Small Town Murder
Ever thought your quaint little town was boring? Small Town Murder will either confirm your suspicions or make you grateful for the lack of excitement. Comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman explore murders in small towns, adding a dash of humor to the macabre. It’s like The Andy Griffith Show, but with more homicide.
Check it out: Small Town Murder
4. The Bakersfield Three
When two friends go missing and another is found murdered, what’s a mother to do? In The Bakersfield Three, three mothers take justice into their own hands, navigating twists and turns that would make a pretzel jealous. It’s a tale of mystery, resilience, and the lengths a parent will go to uncover the truth.
Listen here: The Bakersfield Three
5. Missing Niamh
In 2002, 18-year-old Niamh Maye vanished without a trace. Missing Niamh takes you on a journey through the investigation, the family’s relentless search, and the mysteries that still linger. It’s a poignant reminder that sometimes, the scariest stories are the ones without endings.
Tune in at: Missing Niamh
6. Cold
If you thought your ex was bad, wait until you hear Cold. This podcast unravels the chilling story of Susan Powell’s disappearance, her husband’s suspicious behavior, and a family saga that will make you appreciate your own relatives, no matter how quirky they are.
Check it out: Cold
7. Dark Valley
Dark Valley explores the unsolved murders of the Connecticut River Valley, delving into the lives of the victims and the elusive killer. It’s a deep dive into a chilling case that will have you triple-checking your locks at night.
Listen here: Dark Valley
8. In the Dark
This isn’t your typical bedtime story. In the Dark investigates criminal cases that highlight flaws in the justice system, from a kidnapped boy in Minnesota to a controversial conviction in Mississippi. It’s the kind of podcast that makes you question everything you thought you knew about law and order.
Tune in at: In the Dark
9. True Crime Bullsh**
For those who like their true crime with a side of relentless investigation, True Crime Bullsh** is a serialized podcast focusing on the meticulous and enigmatic serial killer, Israel Keyes. Host Josh Hallmark sifts through FBI files and interviews to piece together the puzzle of Keyes’ crimes. It’s like assembling IKEA furniture, but with more murder.
Check it out: True Crime Bullsh**
10. Anatomy of Murder
Ever wanted to be a fly on the wall during a murder investigation? Anatomy of Murder gives you that insider perspective, as hosts dissect homicide cases and reveal the intricate details behind each crime. It’s like CSI, but without the questionable science and over-the-top acting.
Listen here: Anatomy of Murder
11. Finding Cleo
Finding Cleo is a heart-wrenching tale of a family’s search for their missing sister, Cleo, who was taken by child services in the 1970s and never seen again. The podcast uncovers the dark history of Indigenous child apprehension in Canada, making you question how such tragedies could occur.
Tune in at: Finding Cleo
12. Someone Knows Something
In Someone Knows Something, filmmaker David Ridgen investigates unsolved cases, bringing fresh eyes and new hope to cold cases. Each season tackles a different mystery, proving that sometimes, the past doesn’t stay buried.
Check it out: Someone Knows Something
13. Bear Brook
Imagine solving a cold case with nothing but determination and a podcast. Bear Brook tells the story of how two barrels with unidentified bodies were discovered in New Hampshire, and the decades-long quest to uncover their identities. It’s a testament to the power of persistence.
Listen here: Bear Brook
14. Tom Brown’s Body
High school senior Tom Brown disappeared in 2016, leaving a small Texas town rife with rumors and suspicion. Tom Brown’s Body investigates the mystery, exploring the complexities of the case and the community’s search for answers.
Tune in at: Tom Brown’s Body
15. Sweet Bobby
Catfishing reaches new heights in Sweet Bobby, where a woman finds herself entangled in a decade-long deception. This podcast unravels the intricate web of lies, leaving you questioning how well you truly know your online friends.
Check it out: Sweet Bobby
16. Killer Psyche
Former FBI profiler Candice DeLong takes you inside the minds of killers in Killer Psyche. Each episode explores the psychology behind infamous crimes, making you wonder what really makes someone snap.
Listen here: Killer Psyche
17. The Piketon Massacre
If family feuds and small-town secrets pique your interest, The Piketon Massacre is your ticket. This podcast delves into the notorious 2016 murders of eight members of the Rhoden family in Piketon, Ohio. As the investigation unfolds, you’ll uncover layers of betrayal, suspicion, and the dark underbelly of rural life. It’s a gripping tale that will make you second-guess attending your next family reunion.
Listen here: The Piketon Massacre
18. Small Town Dicks
Ever wondered what really goes on behind the “Welcome to Our Town” signs? Small Town Dicks pulls back the curtain on small-town crime cases, narrated by the detectives who solved them. Hosted by actress Yeardley Smith (the voice of Lisa Simpson) and real-life twin detectives Dan and Dave, this podcast offers an insider’s look into the crimes that disturb the peace in quaint communities. It’s like Mayberry meets Law & Order, with a dash of sibling rivalry.
Check it out: Small Town Dicks
19. Necronomipod
For those who like their true crime served with a side of the paranormal and a generous pour of dark humor, Necronomipod is a must-listen. Hosts Mike, Ian, and Dave crack open beers and discuss topics ranging from serial killers to alien abductions, all while keeping the banter as dark as their subject matter. It’s the perfect blend of chills and chuckles, best enjoyed with the lights on and a cold one in hand.
Tune in at: Necronomipod
While we may not serve up true crime tales here at CreepyBonfire, we’ve got something just as spine-tingling. Confessions of the Unknown is our own podcast that brings chilling, thrilling, and often unexplained real-life experiences into the spotlight. If you’re into strange encounters and the kind of stories that stick with you long after dark, you’ll want to give it a listen. Check it out here: Confessions of the Unknown
